How to Spot a Fake Cat Breeder on Instagram & Facebook: 8 Red Flags Every Maine Coon Buyer Should Know
Buying a Maine Coon kitten is an exciting experience, but unfortunately, social media has made it easier than ever for scammers to prey on unsuspecting buyers.
Instagram and Facebook are full of beautiful kitten photos, adorable videos, and accounts claiming to represent reputable breeders. The problem? Not every account is what it appears to be.
Some scammers steal photos from legitimate breeders, create fake cattery profiles, and advertise kittens they don’t actually own. Others impersonate established breeding programs to collect deposits from multiple unsuspecting families.
Before sending money or committing to a kitten, take a few minutes to investigate the breeder. Here are eight red flags to watch for.
1. Inconsistent Photos Throughout Their Instagram Grid
One of the easiest ways to spot a potentially fake breeder account is to look closely at the photos throughout their profile.
Do the cats and kittens actually appear to live in the same environment?
When you’re looking at a legitimate home-based cattery, you should start recognizing familiar surroundings. You might see the same cat trees, toys, flooring, furniture, rooms, and even family members appearing in different photos and videos.
Scam accounts often steal pictures from multiple breeders. As a result, their Instagram grid can look like a collection of unrelated photos taken in completely different homes.
Pay attention to:
- Different flooring, furniture, and wall colors in supposedly recent photos.
- Toys and cat trees that never appear in the same environment.
- Cats that seem to be photographed in entirely different homes.
- Dramatically different photo quality and backgrounds.
- Kittens that appear in one post but never again.
A legitimate breeder should be able to show you consistent photos and videos of their cats living in their actual environment.
2. No Website — Or a Website That Doesn’t Match Their Social Media
A professional breeding program should have an established online presence beyond Instagram or Facebook.
A website gives buyers an opportunity to learn about the breeder, their breeding practices, health testing, available kittens, parent cats, policies, and application process.
However, simply having a website doesn’t automatically make someone legitimate.
Take the time to compare the website with their social media accounts.
Do the same adult cats appear on both platforms? Do the kittens advertised on Instagram match the kittens listed on the website? Are the names, colors, and photos consistent?
Scammers sometimes create websites using stolen photos from legitimate catteries. Others may impersonate an existing breeder by copying their website information and pictures.
If the website shows completely different cats than the Instagram account, or the information doesn’t line up, that’s a reason to investigate further.
3. Use Google Reverse Image Search
This is one of the most important steps you can take before purchasing a kitten online.
Scammers frequently steal photos from legitimate breeders, sometimes using pictures that have been circulating online for years.
Google’s reverse image search can help you find out whether a kitten’s photo appears somewhere else on the internet.
Here’s how:
- Save a photo of the kitten or cat being advertised.
- Open Google and go to Google Lens.
- Upload the photo or use the image search option.
- Look through the matching and visually similar images.
- Pay attention to whether the photo belongs to another breeder, website, or social media account.
If you find the exact same kitten photo on another breeder’s website or an older social media post, investigate before moving forward.
You can also reverse-search pictures of the adult breeding cats, not just the available kittens.
Finding a photo on another website isn’t automatically proof of fraud. Breeders sometimes share photos, and legitimate content can be reposted. But if someone is advertising another breeder’s kittens as their own, that’s a serious warning sign.
4. Ask About Their Breeder Permit or Registration
Depending on where a breeder lives, they may be required to register with their state, county, or local government.
Some breeders may also fall under USDA licensing requirements depending on their operation and applicable federal regulations.
Ask whether the breeder has a local business license, breeder permit, or other applicable registration.
If they provide a permit number, take the time to verify it with the issuing agency when possible.
A permit or registration number can be a helpful indicator that the breeder operates an established business and is willing to be transparent.
Important: Not every state or county requires a specific breeder permit. The absence of a permit number does not automatically mean someone is a scammer. Requirements vary by location and type of operation.
However, when a breeder does have applicable permits or registrations, it’s another piece of information you can use to establish credibility.
5. They Won’t Video Chat or Show You the Kitten Live
A legitimate breeder should be able to arrange a live video interaction so you can see the kitten and the environment where it is being raised.
Be cautious if someone:
- Makes excuses every time you request a video call.
- Only sends prerecorded videos.
- Refuses to show the kitten in real time.
- Claims their camera or phone isn’t working.
- Sends the same few photos repeatedly but never provides new ones.
A live video call is not absolute proof that someone is legitimate, but it adds another layer of verification.
Ask to see the kitten moving around, interacting with its littermates, or playing with a familiar toy.
6. They Pressure You to Send a Deposit Immediately
Scammers often create a sense of urgency.
They may tell you that several families are interested, another buyer is about to send a deposit, or you need to pay immediately to reserve the kitten.
While legitimate breeders can certainly have waiting lists and interested buyers, they should not make you feel pressured into sending money before you’ve had an opportunity to verify who they are.
Be especially cautious of:
- Requests for immediate payment.
- Changing payment instructions.
- Unusual payment methods.
- Deposits sent to unrelated individuals.
- Refusal to provide a written agreement or receipt.
Always verify the breeder before sending money.
7. Their Reviews and Testimonials Don’t Add Up
Testimonials can be helpful, but don’t assume every screenshot of a happy buyer is genuine.
Look for independent reviews on Google, Facebook, and other platforms.
Pay attention to whether the reviews appear to come from real people with established accounts.
You can also ask the breeder whether they have previous kitten families who are willing to share their experiences.
A reputable breeding program should be comfortable discussing its history, practices, and relationships with previous buyers.
Be cautious of accounts with hundreds of followers but very little genuine engagement or verifiable customer feedback.
8. They Have Multiple Accounts or Impersonation Profiles
One particularly concerning scam involves someone pretending to be an established breeder.
They may copy a legitimate cattery’s name, logo, website information, and photographs while creating a slightly different social media username.
Before contacting a breeder, make sure you’re communicating through their actual account.
If you find multiple profiles using the same cattery name or photos, contact the breeder through their official website or a previously verified contact method to confirm which account belongs to them.
Never assume an account is legitimate just because it has the correct logo and pictures.
The Bottom Line: Do Your Homework Before Buying a Kitten
Maine Coons are a significant investment, and choosing a breeder should involve more than falling in love with a cute kitten photo.
Take the time to research the cattery, verify its online presence, ask questions, and make sure the person you’re communicating with is actually the breeder they claim to be.
A reputable breeder should be willing to answer reasonable questions about their cats, health testing, breeding practices, and kitten-raising process.
Don’t let the excitement of finding your perfect kitten cause you to overlook warning signs.
A few minutes of research can save you thousands of dollars and a tremendous amount of heartbreak.
At Southern Nevada Maine Coons, we believe prospective kitten families deserve transparency, honest communication, and the opportunity to learn about the breeding program behind their kitten. We encourage every buyer to do their research and make an informed decision before placing a deposit.
Your future kitten is worth the extra effort!





